To his Excellency Beriah Magoffin Governor of Kentucky:

The undersigned petitioners citizens and residents of Muhlenberg county would respectfully represent to your Excellency that they have learned that S. P. Love- who Stands Indicted in the Circuit court of this County on a charge of Manslaughter in Klling W. M. Little in the town of South Carrollton, in this County, in the year 1857 is about to apply for a pardon. they beg to join him in the prayer- they are aware that it is not usual to pardon before trial, but if any case ever justified it this does he has been under Indictment for near fouryears — there has been two trials and in both the Jury was unable to agree.

Many of your petitioners have been witnesses in the case and they believe Love was reduced to the wretched necessityofKillingLittle,beingKilledbyhim or leavingthe country — the evidence given in the first trial certified to by the Clerk of our court will be laid before you which will justify this conclusion. M^r Love is a good citizen of but small means with a young and growing family dependant upon him for support and they think he ought not to be further held to devote all his time and means to defend himself against the prosecution but pray that he may be discharged by a pardon
South Carrollton June 1^st 1861

Ja^s W Sulllivan P M So. Carrollton Ky
1 James Henry "
2 Baley Duham "
3 C, L M^cCown "
4 Charles L Morehead "
5 Charles Morehead Sr "
6 Nathaniel Howard "
7 J, R, Nicholls. "
8 Jas. P. M^cIntire "
9 Jas Peveler "
10 L. W. Kincheloe "
11 Tho^s Bruce "
12 Abel Vaughn "
13 B Y Davis "
14 Isaac Clark "
15 James W Johnson "
16 John Clark "
17 W. H. Walker "
18 Geo L Cabaniss "
19 G. T. Davis "
20 T. R Clark "
21 J F Jones "
22 Ja^s W Wallace "
23 GEo N Smalley "
24 W. F. Finch "
25 W. L. Finch "
26 E Finch "
27 N. G. Ferguson "
28 Andrew J Keller "
29 R. P. Kincheloe "
30 Joseph Gassett Muhlenberg County
31 Robert Clark "
32 Philander E Langley So Carrollton
33 John Kittinger "

34 Joseph Kenley "
35 D^r A M. Jackson "
36 Ben C. Young "
37 Robt N. Young "
38 Frank. M. Salsburg "
39 Alves Adcock "
40 W, B, Wickliffe "
41 W^m S Humphrey "
42 Jas T Morehead "
43 C,, W,, McBride "
44 A, H, Edwards "
45 E W Davis "
46 Alex, Clark, "
47 John B Hughes "
48 S W Kennedy "
49 Wilson E Conner "
50 J. C. Langley "
51 William Finch "
52 Morris Ranger "
53 John Lendrum "
54 M, W, Gibbs "
55 W, H Burghardt "
56 H, D, Rothrock
57 E O Vandwyne
58 R L Simms
59 R,, S,, Harris,,
60 J. B, Brown
61 A. H. Lovelace
62 C. H. Tappen
63 Wm Fuller
64 Elias. Kincheloe
65 Eli Jonson
66 John Rothrock

67 Jno E Reno
68 Henry Stobaugh
69 J. W. Whealdon
70 J W Hewlett
71 R, B, Hall
72 B. S. Hewlett
73 N. G. Rothrock,
74 A. H. Kincheloe
75 Ja^s Wolcott
76 John Gregory
77 C. W. Rothrock
78 E M Blacklock
79 R, A, Carbon
80 W G Martin
81 G W York
82 G K, Wall
83 N. W. Buckley
84 L H Martin
85 W^m[Tirham]
86 Gus Thompson
87 W,, L,, Foster
88 B. C. Bennett
89 [...][Rinsley]
90 [...] Drake
91 Peter Shaves
92 Elijah Hughs
93 James R Mason
94 Jess Taylor
95 W^m Anderson
96 E G Hall
97 W. H. Farris
98 Saml Henry
99
100

Alney M^cLean Greenville
Wm K Yost "
Thomas P, Boggess "
B J Jackson "
S. D. Chatham "
P H Baker "
J,, N,, Clifford "
W. F. Mason "
G. W, Short "
F B Hancock "
Nathan Meyer "
J R Reno "
W, G, Jones, "
M, C, Hay "
L. W. W. Vick "
L R Reno "
J H Fanghender "
C. W M^cLean "
H H Johnston "
J, W, Simpson "
E R M^cLean "
W, D, Lindsey "
J. C. Hearn "
M D Hay Co Atto "
Jas, J, Crittenden "
Moses Wickliffe S M C "
J H. Morton M. T. G "
M. C. Ford "
C F Wing "
J M Christian "
T. E. Mann "
H. W. Harris "
N. J. Harris "

J R Lamberth Granville Ky
Samuel. Arnold " "
B. C. Pittman
S. J,, Boyd
Tho^s N Mann
Jesse N Reno Clerk of Muhg Cir Court
Tho J. Jones Deputy Clk —
R. W. M Lean
L W Griffith
A. Salles
H, M. Tinsley
W Hart
Drewry Eades
C P Vincent
James H Young
Henry Tinsley
W^m Tinsley
C, B, Wickliffe
Elias Adcock
David,, Jones
Hann [Vaught]
W. S. Dillman
D. B,, Ham
J P Ward
John Lochry
Henry Eads
W J. Wilkins
Jno Ward
Thomas Baxter
Rudalph Kittinger
Henry Porter

E L. Yonts Muhlenberg county
C Stone "
J. S. Smith "
A T Crawford "
M G Rhoads
Leroy Cundiff
Jacob Johnson
one of last Jury
W. H. Roark
E S Bradley
J. T Quisenberry one of the Grand Jury
A. N. Davis
J. M. Williams
Ja^s E Coleman
Robert E. E. M^cIntire
Joseph L M^cIntire
James. C. Moorman
John Nofsinger
H G Bidwell
S. B. Sturart
M. Glenn
W L Jones
C Watkins
John. W. Lewis
M Neal
J Milligan
John K Sullivan
John M Gish
J L Daniel
Isaac Bard
P. Poole
g W. Eaves
G W Headon one of the Grand Jury

David Gish.
Jas Nofsinger
G B Humphrey
J H scott
[...] C Craig
Harvey. Clark
Jonathan Kittinger
Hall Tooley
Solomon nofsinger
John S [Mollinger]
John K Wickliffe
Amos Benett

Names Residence
Muhlenberg Count
John Pollock "
R t Gregery "
W.. S.. Brown "
Kincheloe Bruce "
James. T. Humphrey "
Arch^d Pollock "
Rob^t Pollack "
Samuel Graham "
W H Young "
Benjamin [Drake] "
Joseph Adcock "
Wm D, Kittinger "
F G. Hall "
James, N, Robertsen "
R,, Poole "
John Whitehouse "
Benjamin Jagoe "
James C Browning "
Martin Comly "
John L Taylor "
James Forehand "
John B Walston "
Jesse Stroud "
James Bruce "
Innis Vincent "
John Meek "
James Rose "

A W garret Muhlenberg County
B A Pittman " "
B W Johns " "
James M Joohnso " "
A. M. Lewis " "
Squire,, Vincent " "
Charles,, Vincent " "
William Bethel " "
George Vincent " "
James H harper " "
James H Highley " "
Thomas Nolls " "
William,, Kyle " "
William,, T,, Vincent " "
James vincent
Joshua Moris
Albet,, G,, Murcer
John,, Stanly
James,, Wilkins
Edward,, Vincent
francis M. Jones
John. W. Lewis
John,, Wright
Earl,, Steward
James [Comrey]

Lewis Griffith Muhlenberg County
Isaac Reed " "
Jackson Ward " "
W^m Grffith " "
James N. Griffith " "
A R Jenkins " "
Tho^s Allen " "
Peter Lam " "
John Simm^s " "
G Flangley " "
W^m Gregory " "
T R Ferguson " "
John Coombes " "
W. H Ham " "
E, G, Smith " "
Leven Watkins " "
Jese Marsee " "
John Reed " "
Jacob Jago " "
S M Curd " "
E Balset " "
Rob^t. Jenkins one of the Grand Jury "
C M kirtley " "
B, F, Tinsley " "
Dixon Beal " "
J, M, Watkins " "
Elijah Wilkins " "

M. Roll Muhlenberg County
R D Reno " "
J B Gish " "
Sherred Jones " "
J. N Rhoades " "
Daniel Overheds " "
William young " "
W. H. Hermon " "
John Straud Jr " "
Charles Morgan " "
W^m. P. Nicholls " "
Thomas. J. Clark "
C. F. Robertson Witness for Commonwealth
James Carbon " "
Hutson Brown Muhlenberg County
J S Lucus One of the Jury last trial
Mat Neal
Jno D Davis
Jno Brown
Francis. Robertson
John Wright witness for Defence
Aaron Wickliffe Muhlenberg County
G. W. Wade " "
R. E. Humphrey " "
W M^cGown
D. J. Gish

John S Young
H J Gotten
Jim Humphey
Jim Corn
J B Millard
R Sullivan
J. Lutham
A W Davis
R. W. Bodine
Witness for Commonwealth